Research in Action
Comments (0) Powerful Learning is personalized, rigorous, and relevant.
Working on primary documents.
Formal research papers are never a favorite activity in high school. I have assigned them for years and each time I realize that my students cannot see the value in the process unless the topic is important and of interest to them. With Graduation Project, the research paper is directly linked to the student’s choice but this component remains the biggest hurdle and cause for discontent. However, there are students who dive in and relish their new learning. Nadiya is one of those students and I just have to share a recent breakthrough for her. Nadiya is studying the slaves of Western North Carolina, specifically those who served at the Smith-McDowell house. She has been using primary documents to uncover the conditions endured by the slaves there as compared to the slaves in other parts of the country. She happened upon George Avery, a slave who gained emancipation and land from his owners. Her research focus narrowed down to focus on the conditions of Mr. Avery’s life and his progress as a free man. Her research uncovered a learning gem for her. She happened upon a current article discussing his life that in her words “was inaccurate and held many assumptions that could not be proven through the primary documents she had been studying.” I asked her if she shared her discovery with her mentor, a professor of history at UNCA. She had not done so and proceeded to send him the link and her assessment. How delightful!
Much of our class is stored online in a Moodle platform. She posted this update, “I don’t want to brag myself but this is what my mentor said when I sent him a link to an article that made a whole lot terrible assumptions. This is something you cannot do unless you can back it up. You cannot make things up unless you can prove them.”
His reply was, “Thank you for forwarding this article to me. I would certainly like to see his sources. Unless there are documents to back this up, there is a great deal of speculation and assumptions about George Avery and W.W. McDowell. I am going to see if some friends with WNC and McDowell history can substantiate any of this. There are a lot of assumptions about McDowell’s intent expressed. Good research and great questions!”
Nadiya immersed herself in her topic and became an expert. Her careful exploration of primary documents found in the archives of the Smith-McDowell House Museum prepared her to question another source for accuracy and substance. This spark of independent learning validated her hard work and added fuel to the fire of her inquiry. She is amazed and aware that the research process has rewards that go beyond the typical student’s need to just get it over with.
The system works when it is personalized, rigorous, and relevant.
Good reminder.
Themocracy